REM sleep deprivation in horses

Pathophysiology, clinical signs and differential diagnosis from narcolepsy

Introduction

A horse that suddenly falls asleep on its feet, buckles at the forelimbs or even collapses during apparent episodes of drowsiness is frequently described as suffering from narcolepsy.

In reality, in the horse, many of these episodes are attributable to a different condition: sleep deprivation, and in particular deprivation of REM (Rapid Eye Movement) sleep.

This is a clinically significant disorder, at times underdiagnosed, which can seriously compromise the horse's welfare and cause substantial traumatic injury.

What makes this condition distinctive lies in the physiology of equine sleep: the horse is perfectly able to rest while standing on all four limbs, but it cannot fully meet all its physiological sleep requirements without periodically lying down.

Understanding this distinction is fundamental in order to recognise the problem early, identify its causes and plan a correct diagnostic and therapeutic approach.

1. The physiology of sleep in the horse

The horse is a species characterised by polyphasic sleep, distributed across numerous episodes over the 24 hours, predominantly during the night.

Equine sleep comprises two main states:

• NREM sleep (Non-Rapid Eye Movement): characterised by a progressive reduction in brain activity and in the level of alertness. It can also occur while the horse is standing.
• REM sleep (Rapid Eye Movement): characterised by distinctive brain activity, rapid eye movements and a marked reduction in skeletal muscle tone, known as REM atonia.

Why can the horse sleep standing up?

The horse possesses a complex anatomical and biomechanical system, commonly known as the stay apparatus, which allows it to remain standing with relatively little muscular effort.

This evolutionary adaptation allows the animal, as a prey species, to alternate periods of rest and alertness while retaining the ability to react quickly to danger.

During REM sleep, however, there is a profound reduction in the tone of the postural muscles, which is incompatible with stable standing.

For this reason the horse, in order to obtain physiological and continuous REM sleep, must normally lie down.

Lateral recumbency is particularly favourable to complete muscular relaxation; REM sleep can nevertheless also occur in sternal recumbency, provided the head and neck are adequately supported.

How much does a horse sleep?

Studies of equine sleep behaviour report a total duration generally between about 3 and 5 hours in 24, with significant variability related to age, environment, management and individual characteristics.

REM sleep accounts for only a fraction of this time, often in the order of a few tens of minutes a day.

Despite its relatively short duration, this phase is an essential physiological component of the normal sleep cycle.

It is important to stress that a horse may spend many hours apparently at rest, even sleeping on its feet, without obtaining a sufficient amount of REM sleep.

2. What is REM sleep deprivation syndrome?

The term sleep deprivation describes a condition in which the quantity or quality of sleep is insufficient for the physiological needs of the body.

In the horse, selective or predominant deprivation of REM sleep is of particular importance.

When a horse avoids lying down for prolonged periods, it may continue to obtain episodes of NREM sleep while standing, but it cannot adequately complete its sleep cycle.

As this condition persists, the physiological pressure for REM sleep increases — that is, the body's need to recover this phase.

In more advanced cases, episodes of involuntary entry into REM sleep may occur while the horse is still standing.

The consequent loss of postural muscle tone causes a sudden collapse, generally most evident in the forelimbs.

The horse may buckle at the knees, drop abruptly or even fall, waking immediately as it loses its balance.

These episodes are frequently interpreted as narcoleptic attacks, but the underlying pathophysiological mechanism is different.

REM sleep deprivation is not necessarily a primary neurological disease: very often it is the consequence of a painful, environmental, behavioural or management condition that prevents the horse from lying down and resting adequately.

3. The main causes of REM sleep deprivation

REM sleep deprivation can have a multifactorial origin.

It is useful to distinguish conditions that physically prevent the horse from lying down from those that cause a behavioural inhibition of recumbency.

3.1 Musculoskeletal pain

Pain is one of the most important clinical causes to investigate.

The horse may avoid lying down not so much because of pain associated with recumbency itself, as because of the difficulty or discomfort it experiences during the movements needed to get down to the ground and, above all, to get back up.

Potentially predisposing conditions include:

• Chronic osteoarthritis, particularly of the hindlimb joints.
• Disease of the hock and stifle.
• Painful foot conditions, including chronic forms of laminitis.
• Thoracolumbar pain and disease of the sacroiliac region.
• Muscle weakness, proprioceptive deficits and neurological conditions that compromise the ability to rise.

The problem can set up a vicious circle: the horse avoids lying down, accumulates a REM sleep deficit, shows collapsing episodes and falls, and may sustain further traumatic injury.

3.2 Environmental and management factors

Sleep is a behaviour that is particularly vulnerable to environmental conditions.

A horse may give up lying down if it does not perceive the environment as sufficiently safe, or if the physical characteristics of the place do not allow comfortable recumbency.

The main factors to assess include:

• The surface, depth and quality of the bedding.
• The size of the stable and the space available for lying down and getting up.
• The presence of noise or night-time disturbance.
• Excessive or continuous lighting.
• Sudden changes of environment and routine.
• Unfavourable weather conditions in outdoor resting areas.

A move from group management to individual housing, or vice versa, can also alter resting behaviour.

3.3 Social and hierarchical factors, and vigilance behaviour

Sleep behaviour in the horse is closely influenced by the social structure of the group and by the individual's sense of security.

As a prey species, the horse shows particularly well-developed vigilance behaviour, which serves an important protective function during periods of rest.

In socially stable groups it is possible to observe an alternation between individuals resting in recumbency and others that remain standing, maintaining a higher level of vigilance.

This mechanism, known as shared vigilance (group vigilance), contributes to the security perceived by members of the group and may encourage lying down.

Hierarchical position can influence resting behaviour through different mechanisms.

In subordinate animals, especially where space is limited, lying down may be hindered by the presence of dominant individuals, by agonistic interactions or by difficulty in accessing resting areas that are sufficiently safe and comfortable.

In particularly vigilant horses, or those with strong social bonds, on the other hand, a high level of attention towards the environment and towards other members of the group could interfere with their willingness to lie down.

This second behaviour may be of particular interest in mares with a foal and, potentially, in some adult horses that frequently adopt vigilance behaviour towards the group.

It is important to note, however, that the vigilance function does not necessarily coincide with hierarchical dominance, and that there is currently insufficient evidence to state that dominant animals are systematically more predisposed to REM sleep deprivation.

In particular, the hypothesis that an older dominant mare might reduce her own rest in order to maintain greater control over the group is ethologically plausible, but it requires individual assessment and cannot be considered a demonstrated pathological mechanism.

Ethological observations further suggest that mares with a foal may show changes in lying times compared with other adult horses, indicating a possible role for maternal behaviour and vigilance.

Taken together, these elements underline how the quality of rest depends not only on the physical possibility of lying down, but also on perceived security and on the social dynamics of the group.

3.4 Individual housing, loss of shared vigilance and the risk of REM sleep deprivation

A further potentially predisposing factor for REM sleep deprivation is the change in resting behaviour that can follow individual housing.

In natural or semi-natural conditions, horses living in socially stable groups may benefit from a system of shared vigilance, in which the presence of alert individuals contributes to the security perceived by those resting in recumbency.

Individual housing can disrupt this mechanism, depriving the horse of the ability to benefit fully from the vigilance exercised by other members of the group.

In some horses this could lead to an increased state of environmental alertness, a reduced tendency to lie down and a consequent alteration of sleep architecture.

The scientific literature has shown that the move from group management to individual housing can alter resting times and lying behaviour.

A study published in the Equine Veterinary Journal by Helmerich and colleagues compared the resting behaviour of young horses kept in an individual stable, in an individual paddock and in a paddock in pairs.

The authors observed a tendency towards increased lying behaviour in the conditions with greater social contact. However, the differences between conditions did not reach statistical significance and must therefore be interpreted as preliminary findings.

It is important to stress that visual and auditory contact with horses in adjacent stables does not necessarily reproduce all the conditions of social security offered by life in a group.

Nevertheless, individual housing does not inevitably lead to REM sleep deprivation. Many horses manage to adapt to this condition and to maintain adequate resting behaviour.

The clinical risk could be greater in horses that are particularly vigilant, poorly adaptable to environmental change or used to living in stable social groups, above all when individual housing is combined with other predisposing factors such as musculoskeletal pain, inadequate bedding or frequent night-time disturbance.

The loss of the security provided by shared vigilance must therefore be considered a possible predisposing factor for REM sleep deprivation, particularly in horses that show a persistent reduction in lying behaviour in the absence of obvious physical impediments.

This interpretation is consistent with current ethological and physiological knowledge, although further studies are required to define the specific contribution of social isolation to the development of the clinical syndrome.

3.5 Advanced age

Older horses may present several predisposing factors for REM sleep deprivation at the same time: arthritis, reduced muscular strength, difficulty with flexion movements and altered balance.

In these animals, a failure to lie down may mistakenly be interpreted as a normal consequence of ageing.

On the contrary, the appearance of drowsiness and collapsing episodes should always prompt a search for a clinical cause.

Age can influence sleep architecture, as well as increasing the likelihood of painful conditions that interfere with lying down.

4. Clinical signs

The clinical presentation can range from occasional episodes of drowsiness to repeated collapse and traumatic falls.

4.1 Behavioural signs

The horse may show:

• Excessive drowsiness during the day.
• Prolonged periods of immobility with the head and neck lowered.
• Partially or completely closed eyes.
• Progressive loss of muscle tone in the neck.
• Apparent difficulty in maintaining a state of alertness.

4.2 Collapsing episodes

The most characteristic sign is buckling of the forelimbs during an episode of drowsiness.

The horse may initially lower its head, progressively flex the knees and suddenly lose its balance.

Contact with the ground, or the abrupt movement of falling, generally produces immediate waking, followed by a rapid return to standing.

In some horses these episodes are repeated many times during the day.

4.3 Episodes of falling asleep and collapsing during grooming and handling

A particularly interesting clinical manifestation of REM sleep deprivation is the appearance of episodes of drowsiness and postural collapse during routine handling of the horse.

In some horses the episodes are observed during grooming, preparation for work, shoeing or when the horse is held still on a lead rope.

The horse may initially show a progressive lowering of the head, reduced alertness and partial or complete closing of the eyes, culminating in a sudden buckling of the forelimbs, sometimes followed by a fall.

These signs have been described in the equine clinical literature and may be associated with chronic REM sleep deprivation.

One possible pathophysiological interpretation is that conditions of relative immobility, calm and reduced environmental stimulation allow the sleep pressure accumulated by the horse to emerge, facilitating involuntary entry into a state of sleep that is incompatible with remaining standing.

Grooming could therefore represent a situation in which the horse temporarily reduces its state of vigilance, allowing the physiological need for sleep to prevail over the mechanisms that normally maintain wakefulness.

However, the appearance of episodes during grooming or following contact with the owner is not specific to sleep deprivation.

In narcolepsy with cataplexy, too, episodes triggered by external stimuli have been described, including handling and certain everyday activities.

Making the distinction therefore requires particular attention to the sequence of events: progressive drowsiness preceding the collapse points towards an episode of inappropriate sleep, whereas a sudden loss of muscle tone during apparently full wakefulness may suggest a cataplectic event.

Grooming and handling should therefore be regarded as possible contexts in which episodes appear, but they are not in themselves diagnostic criteria for distinguishing REM sleep deprivation from narcolepsy.

The assessment must be completed with a careful history, observation of resting behaviour, video monitoring and the exclusion of other causes of collapse.

From a safety point of view, it is important to consider that these episodes may occur while the horse is tied up or being handled, increasing the risk of injury both to the animal and to the people present.

4.4 Traumatic injuries

A particularly suggestive clinical finding is the presence of recurrent skin lesions over the dorsal surfaces of the knees and, at times, the fetlocks.

Abrasions, grazes, hair loss, swelling and wounds of varying severity may be present.

The presence of bilateral, recurrent lesions on the knees, combined with episodes of drowsiness, should always lead the veterinary surgeon to consider a sleep disorder among the possible diagnoses.

These lesions are not, however, pathognomonic and require careful differential diagnosis.

5. Narcolepsy and sleep deprivation: two different conditions

Narcolepsy is a neurological disorder of the regulation of sleep and wakefulness, characterised by an alteration of the mechanisms controlling the transition between these states.

In human medicine, some forms of narcolepsy are associated with dysfunction of the hypocretin/orexin system, which is involved in maintaining wakefulness and in stabilising sleep–wake transitions.

Signs compatible with narcolepsy have also been described in the horse, but the condition is considered rare and its pathophysiological mechanisms are not fully characterised.

A particularly important phenomenon is cataplexy: a sudden loss of muscle tone occurring during wakefulness, often in association with emotional stimuli.

Cataplexy must not be confused with the loss of muscle tone that follows entry into REM sleep in a horse severely deprived of this phase.

Main clinical differences

Feature	REM sleep deprivation	Narcolepsy
Mechanism	Insufficient quantity of REM sleep	Altered regulation of sleep and wakefulness
Cause	Often secondary to pain, environment or management	Primary neurological disorder
Episodes	Typically during drowsiness	Possible abnormal sleep–wake transitions or cataplexy
Loss of muscle tone	Associated with entry into REM sleep	May appear during wakefulness
Lying down	Often absent or greatly reduced	Not necessarily reduced
Grooming and handling	May encourage episodes during relaxation	May be associated with cataplectic episodes
Treatment	Correction of the causes preventing sleep	Specialist management of the condition

Simply observing a horse buckling at the forelimbs does not allow a diagnosis of narcolepsy.

The most important clinical distinction concerns the context in which the loss of muscle tone occurs: during a transition towards sleep, or during an apparently preserved state of wakefulness.

Even this element must be interpreted with caution, however, since definitive diagnosis may require specialist investigation.

6. The veterinary diagnostic approach

Diagnosis requires a systematic approach, aimed both at characterising the collapsing episodes and at identifying any predisposing conditions.

6.1 History

History taking should include information on the frequency of the episodes, the time of day at which they occur, their duration, the presence of triggering stimuli and any traumatic injuries.

It is particularly important to ask the owner whether the horse is actually seen lying down.

An absence of recumbency reported by the owner is not, however, sufficient to confirm sleep deprivation: many horses lie down mainly at night, when they are not being observed.

It is also useful to establish whether the episodes occur mainly during grooming, shoeing, preparation for work or other situations characterised by immobility and reduced environmental stimulation.

6.2 Video monitoring

Continuous video recording, preferably over several 24-hour cycles, is a particularly useful tool.

It allows assessment of:

• The frequency and duration of episodes of lying down.
• How the horse lies down and gets up.
• The presence of environmental disturbance.
• Behaviour during collapsing episodes.
• Any social interactions that interfere with rest.

It is important to note that video monitoring documents resting behaviour, but on its own it cannot identify the electrophysiological stages of sleep with certainty.

6.3 Clinical and orthopaedic examination

The veterinary assessment must include a general clinical examination and, where indicated, a thorough orthopaedic and neurological examination.

The aim is to identify painful conditions or functional deficits that may make lying down difficult.

In older horses, or those with suspected musculoskeletal disease, targeted radiographic and ultrasonographic investigations may be indicated.

6.4 Polysomnography

Polysomnography is the reference method for the objective characterisation of sleep stages.

It involves the simultaneous recording of several physiological parameters, in particular:

• Electroencephalography (EEG), to assess brain activity.
• Electromyography (EMG), to analyse muscle tone.
• Electro-oculography (EOG), to detect eye movements.

These recordings make it possible to distinguish wakefulness, NREM sleep and REM sleep, and to assess any alterations in sleep architecture.

Its clinical use in the horse nevertheless remains limited to specialist and research settings.

7. Differential diagnoses

Not all episodes of buckling or collapse in the horse are attributable to sleep disorders.

Other conditions must be considered, including:

• Neurological disease with postural deficits.
• Muscle weakness.
• Severe orthopaedic pain.
• Syncopal episodes.
• Seizures.
• Metabolic or systemic disorders causing weakness or altered consciousness.

The presence of altered consciousness, abnormal movements, persistent neurological deficits or difficulty in regaining a standing position requires specific further investigation.

A useful point in clinical assessment is that the horse with REM sleep deprivation may have an essentially normal neurological examination between episodes.

This finding is not, however, sufficient to rule out other conditions.

8. Treatment and management

There is no single pharmacological treatment for REM sleep deprivation in the horse.

The therapeutic approach must be directed at correcting the causes that prevent or reduce normal lying behaviour.

8.1 Pain management

Where musculoskeletal disease is present, treatment must be targeted at the diagnosed condition.

Pain control, through appropriate pharmacological, rehabilitative or interventional therapy, can improve the horse's ability and willingness to lie down.

In cases of chronic arthritis, the treatment plan should also consider the management of exercise, the quality of surfaces and the maintenance of muscle function.

8.2 Improving environmental conditions

It is essential to provide a resting area that is sufficiently large, safe, dry and comfortable.

Adequately deep, non-slip bedding can make it easier to lie down and get up, particularly in older horses or those with orthopaedic disease.

Management must also limit, as far as possible, night-time disturbance and conditions that create insecurity.

8.3 Social management

In horses kept in groups it is advisable to assess the interactions between individuals and to check that each one has the opportunity to rest undisturbed.

In individually housed horses, especially where hypervigilance is suspected, it may be useful to consider management changes aimed at improving the perceived social security.

These may include greater contact with compatible companions, periods in shared paddocks and, where possible and appropriate, management in small stable groups.

These measures must be adapted to the individual horse, taking into account temperament, clinical condition and safety.

8.4 Monitoring the response

The response to treatment should be assessed through a reduction in collapsing episodes, any return of lying behaviour and the progressive healing of traumatic lesions.

In complex cases, repeated video monitoring can provide useful information on the effectiveness of the measures taken.

It is important to avoid interpreting an increase in time spent lying down as definitive proof in itself that REM sleep has returned to normal.

9. Prognosis

The prognosis depends mainly on the underlying cause and on whether it can be corrected.

In horses where the problem is predominantly environmental or management-related, restoring adequate resting conditions can produce significant improvement.

In horses with chronic orthopaedic disease, the prognosis depends on the severity of the pain and on whether a sufficient ability to lie down and get up can be recovered.

The presence of repeated episodes of collapse is also an important risk factor for injury.

The time needed to recover a normal sleep profile is not precisely defined in the horse and can vary considerably.

10. Conclusions

REM sleep deprivation is a clinical condition of considerable interest in equine medicine, often underestimated or confused with narcolepsy.

Recognising the characteristic signs — in particular daytime drowsiness, buckling of the forelimbs and recurrent traumatic lesions on the knees — makes it possible to raise diagnostic suspicion at an early stage.

A particularly interesting clinical feature is the possible appearance of episodes during grooming, shoeing or routine handling of the horse: situations in which a reduced state of vigilance can allow pre-existing sleep pressure to emerge.

The assessment must not, however, be limited to the apparent neurological signs.

It is necessary to consider the horse as a whole, investigating any painful conditions, difficulty with movement, environmental conditions and social factors that may interfere with normal resting behaviour.

Particular attention must be paid to housing conditions and to the horse's ability to express natural resting behaviour.

The loss of shared vigilance, social isolation and environmental insecurity are possible predisposing factors whose contribution must be assessed individually.

REM sleep deprivation is therefore a significant example of how an apparently neurological sign can have a multifactorial origin and require an integrated diagnostic approach.

A horse that sleeps standing up is not necessarily a horse that sleeps enough. And a horse that suddenly buckles at the forelimbs is not necessarily narcoleptic.

Scientific bibliography

1. Greening L., McBride S. (2022). A Review of Equine Sleep: Implications for Equine Welfare. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 9, 916737. DOI: 10.3389/fvets.2022.916737.
2. Helmerich P., Bachmann I., Gygax L. (2025). Comparing lying behaviour of young riding horses on days in an individual indoor box, on an outdoor paddock alone, or in pairs and in the following night. Equine Veterinary Journal, 57(1), 277–281. DOI: 10.1111/evj.14041.
3. Burla J.B., Rufener C., Bachmann I., Gygax L., Patt A., Hillmann E. (2017). Space Allowance of the Littered Area Affects Lying Behavior in Group-Housed Horses. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 4, 23. DOI: 10.3389/fvets.2017.00023.
4. Williams D.C., Aleman M., Holliday T.A., Fletcher D.J., Tharp B., Kass P.H., Steffey E.P., LeCouteur R.A. (2008). Qualitative and quantitative characteristics of the electroencephalogram in normal horses during spontaneous drowsiness and sleep. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine, 22(3), 630–638.
5. Dallaire A., Ruckebusch Y. (1974). Sleep patterns in the pony with observations on partial perceptual deprivation. Physiology & Behavior, 12(5), 789–796.
6. Ruckebusch Y. (1972). The relevance of drowsiness in the circadian cycle of farm animals. Animal Behaviour, 20(4), 637–643.
7. Feist J.D., McCullough D.R. (1976). Behavior Patterns and Communication in Feral Horses. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie, 41, 337–371. DOI: 10.1111/j.1439-0310.1976.tb00947.x.
8. Zimmer L. et al. (2026). Sleep architecture and lying behavior in horses across age groups and two housing systems: an overnight non-invasive EEG study. Text available on PubMed Central.